As a PS3 owner I concur with the poster.
While I would never consider the PS3 a crippled machine in any respect because it DOES fulfill it’s job as a gaming console, and it does very well with adding the bells and whistles of creating a high-definition media experience. However, in the online department it comes out of the gate with a gamer-nation wide “meh”.
Why? Probably because of diversity and three competing major branches of the same company trying to convince the other that the social aspects of Home are worth the trouble.
The Japanese market is practically non-existent in the MMO industry and giving them a MMO-style social network (ala: Second Life) probably just hasn’t appealed to them. Plus, you have to take in to consideration that SCEI is primarily a Japanese company first and foremost so the “headquarters” probably doesn’t put something like this as “first and foremost”.
Not even in America is the MMO industry really that big of a genre. That’s not to say that the USA doesn’t have great MMO’s but generally if it doesn’t have World of Warcraft on it people here usually don’t pay much attention.
So, SCEE (Sony Computer Entertainment Europe) has been handling the project thanks to all of the push and hype that former SCEE CEO Phil Harrison pushed with his Game 3.0 programs at GDC in 2006. However, here we are almost a year and a half later and things haven’t changed. We don’t have the grand super experience that Sony let us peek in to and some of the major system accessories haven’t arrived even though they were going to be touted as something revolutionary right out of the launch.
In-game XMB? nope
Custom soundtracks for games? nope
PS3 Home social system? nope
Accomplishments? nope
Three of the biggest wishes of PS3 owners that keep getting delayed or just never show up.
My take on the whole thing? Home may possibly never come. Why? Well, Home is supposed to expand and create a gaming experience that would incorporate many aspects of Xbox Live (achievements, gamerscore, etc etc) and would make them in to something that would actually be up for everyone to see. Something that was actually, ya know, worth going through the trouble for. However, most of this stuff is also heavily dependent upon developers actually INTEGRATING their games with Home, and since Home has been delayed more and more and has yet to even reach beyond Closed beta it looks like more and more developers might just take a pass on the thing all together.
Why?
Well, why not? They already have the Live architecture there and they are greatly more experienced with creating a social aspect using the dashboards of Live. Why would a 3rd-party dev even waste their time with creating game integration for a social system that has yet to even full decide on a release window? As time goes by more and more developers will come to that bridge and some may cross it and some may just turn around and go back the way they came.
I had high hopes for Home when I first purchased my PS3. I didn’t expect it to be a game or anything other than a trophy/accomplishment system that was mixed with a high-def social mmo where you and your friends could meet and launch games. However, now I don’t even care. By Winter most of the owners will be feeling the same way that I am and actual GAMES will have removed any hype that Home actually managed to gain in the year and a half that it has been announced.
So, in closing, I’m Homeless and, like waiting for Duke Nukem Forever, I probably always will be.